Kill My Idea

Name: Kill My Idea
Author: monteduro

by monteduroversion 1.0.0i★ –iRuns in the cloud

Registry namebiz.killmyidea/killmyidea

Install

Overview

Description from the maker (original English)

Judges startup and side-project ideas: KILL IT, FIX IT or SHIP IT, a 0-100 score and 8 sub-scores.

PopNx MCP’s three pillars

These three are never merged into one score: opinions, measurements and popularity are different things.

User voiceiNo reviews yetReviews open together with accounts in a later step
Our basic checksi3 of 3 passedChecked from public information; code not scanned yet
UsageiVery new★ –

What you can do with it

We have not written a plain-language summary for this one yet. Below are the facts we read from the registry.

Connection: Runs in the cloud
Transport: Streamable HTTP
Category: Other

Install

Pick the AI app you use, then copy the settings.

Before you install

Basic checks: 3 of 3 passed
Runs on the maker’s server: what you ask it goes through their server.
Can do 2 things (tools) judge_idea, get_stats
The registry lists no key to fill in.

You need

Runs in the cloudNothing to install; it connects over the internet

Which app do you use?

ClaudeClaude CodeCursorVS CodeChatGPT

Pick your app above. We remember it, so next time the button says “Install in …”.

Works in Claude on the web, desktop and mobile:

Open Settings → Connectors
Press Add custom connector
Paste the address below and press Add
If it asks you to sign in, sign in with the maker

https://killmyidea.biz/api/mcp

Run this in your terminal

claude mcp add --transport http killmyidea https://killmyidea.biz/api/mcp

Open in Cursor

Or copy the settings yourself

Paste into .cursor/mcp.json in your project, or ~/.cursor/mcp.json

{
  "mcpServers": {
    "killmyidea": {
      "url": "https://killmyidea.biz/api/mcp"
    }
  }
}

Your browser asks to open the app, then the app shows the settings and asks you to confirm. Key values are left empty for you to fill in.

Open in VS Code

Or copy the settings yourself

Paste into .vscode/mcp.json in your project

{
  "servers": {
    "killmyidea": {
      "type": "http",
      "url": "https://killmyidea.biz/api/mcp"
    }
  }
}

Your browser asks to open the app, then the app shows the settings and asks you to confirm. Key values are left empty for you to fill in.

ChatGPT connects only to servers on the internet:

Open ChatGPT on the web → Settings → Connectors (Apps)
Press Create or Add (some plans need Developer mode under Advanced first)
Paste the address below, give it a name and save
If it asks you to sign in, sign in with the maker

https://killmyidea.biz/api/mcp

Menu names can differ slightly by plan and over time.

Your choice stays on this device in a cookie; no account needed.

These settings are generated from the maker’s registry entry. If the README says otherwise, follow the README.

What it can do

Tool names and descriptions exactly as the server reported them on Nov 6, 2026. The maker wrote them, not us; we show them as plain text.

judge_idea
Judge a startup or side-project idea. Returns a verdict (verdict KILL, FIX or SHIP, shown as verdict_label KILL IT, FIX IT or SHIP IT), an overall score, the best_signal, the biggest_risk and the eight scored dimensions. If the idea is too vague to judge, needs_detail is true and
get_stats
How many ideas Kill My Idea has analyzed so far and how many were killed, fixed or shipped. Cached for 5 minutes.

Basic checksi

We check information anyone can see; we have not read the code. Checks that do not apply are left out of the count. · Checked Nov 8, 2026

✓ Pass
Maker matches the repo
The registry name was verified against the domain killmyidea.biz (the registry checks domain ownership)
… Not checked yet
Still maintained
We have not read this repo from GitHub yet
… Not checked yet
Has a licence
We have not read this repo from GitHub yet
✓ Pass
Endpoint responds
Responded in 336 ms (HTTP 200)
– Not applicable
Sign-in with OAuth
No sign-in needed
✓ Pass
No hidden instructions in tool descriptions
Read 2 tool descriptions and found no hidden instructions to the AI

Compared with others in Otheri

More stars than 0% of the other 18475 servers in this category
Published to the registry more recently than 92% of the other 18475 servers in this category
Basic checks equal to or better than 100% of the other 18475 servers in this category

Compared with every active server in this category in the registry. Stars count only when the publisher owns the repo.

Common questions

Is Kill My Idea safe?

It passed 3 of 3 applicable basic checks. We have not read the code. Before adding a key or token, see what access the server asks for and use a key with only the permissions you need.

What keys or codes does it need?

The registry does not list a required key, though some servers ask you to sign in on first use.

Does it run on my computer or in the cloud?

It runs in the maker’s cloud. Connect over the internet with nothing to install, but what you send passes through the maker’s servers.

Is it still maintained?

The GitHub repo last changed –, and the latest version (1.0.0) reached the registry 3 days ago.

Which apps can use it?

Apps that support MCP, such as Claude Desktop, Claude Code, Cursor and VS Code. It connects by URL, so apps that accept remote MCP servers work too, such as ChatGPT in developer mode.

What can I use instead?

In the same category: Spec Driven Development, Remote Desktop Commander, Tethered Trust

Alternatives

Servers in the same category from other makers, sorted by stars.

Reading a card:↓ Downloads per weeki★ GitHub starsiThree pillars: reviews · checks · usageiUpdated = latest version published to the registryi

Spec Driven Development

MCP Server that facilitates spec-driven development workflows, not just Vibe Coding.

by formulahendryEarly↓ 66/wk★ 440Updated 14 months ago

Runs on your computer

Install

Remote Desktop Commander

Remote Desktop Commander: use files, terminal and processes on your own computers from any AI app.

by desktop-commanderGrowing★ 211Updated 3 days ago

Runs in the cloud✓ desktopcommander.app

Install

Tethered Trust

Fit, compatibility and recall checks for AI agents before they buy: verdicts, evidence, receipts.

by tetheredtrust.comVery newUpdated today

Runs in the cloud✓ tetheredtrust.com

Install

README from the maker

Open the README

Copied from the maker’s repo as written. PopNx MCP has not reviewed or endorsed it. HTML, images and scripts are removed. Links lead off this site.

Kill My Idea

Describe a startup idea. Jev decides: KILL IT, FIX IT or SHIP IT.

No generative LLM. One request asks TypeSafe Jev 10 questions in parallel: 8 plain indie-hacker questions scored 0–4, plus the category and whether the idea is understandable.

idea → Jev (8 scores) → each × 25 → weighted average → clarity gate → KILL / FIX / SHIP

1. Install

npm install

2. Environment

cp .env.example .env

TYPESAFE_API_KEY=your_key

The key is only read by api/evaluate.ts and never reaches the browser.

Successful evaluations are archived in SQLite at data/analytics.sqlite by default. Set ANALYTICS_DB_PATH to an absolute path on a persistent disk in production. Users can opt out per request with the checkbox below private history.

SITE_URL (optional) sets the absolute URL used in the canonical and OG/Twitter tags, robots.txt, sitemap.xml, /mcp.md and llms.txt (generated at build time). It defaults to https://killmyidea.biz. The image itself is public/og.png (1200×630).

For UI work without a key, set TYPESAFE_MOCK=1. The API then returns deterministic fake answers labelled MOCK DATA in the raw-data panel. Mock mode is ignored in production.

3. Run locally

npm run dev          # http://127.0.0.1:5317 (serves /api/* and /mcp/ too)

npm test # unit tests npm run benchmark # balanced scoring benchmark; requires the app to be running

Every result has a collapsed "How Jev decided" panel with raw Jev answers, probabilities, confidence, the average, the verdict, latency and token usage. ?debug=1 opens it by default.

4. Build

npm run build        # typecheck + static build in dist/

5. Deploy (Laravel Forge)

The site runs on Forge as a Node server: npm run build for the static assets in dist/, then npm run build:server && npm start to serve the API endpoints. Set TYPESAFE_API_KEY in the site's environment file.

SQLite needs a persistent local disk, which the Forge server provides directly (data/analytics.sqlite); set ANALYTICS_DB_PATH to an absolute path on that disk in production.

Because the SPA is served with an nginx fallback (try_files ... /index.html), every unknown path returns the index page with HTTP 200. Bots probing random URLs therefore show up as pageviews in DataFast. To stop that, change the fallback in the site's nginx configuration (Forge → site → Edit Nginx Configuration) to return 404 for unknown paths if the app has no real routes:

location / {

try_files $uri $uri/ =404; }

Domain move (killmyidea.stemonte.io → killmyidea.biz)

Both domains belong to the same Forge site. The old one answers every request with a 301 to the same path and query on killmyidea.biz, via deploy/nginx-old-domain-redirect.conf, pasted into the site's nginx configuration inside the server block. Keep that redirect for at least a year.

Idea history lives in localStorage, which is per origin. The 301 adds #moved; the inline script in index.html then makes one hop to public/history-transfer.html on the old domain, which returns with its history in the URL fragment (never sent to a server) to be merged. It runs at most once per browser. Remove both once the old domain is retired.

MCP server

api/mcp.ts is a free, public MCP server at /api/mcp (Streamable HTTP, no auth). It is stateless: every POST is one JSON-RPC message answered with plain JSON, there are no sessions and GET returns 405. Tools:

judge_idea(idea, goal?, do_not_archive?): same pipeline as /api/evaluate (api/_judge.ts), returns the verdict, score, best signal, biggest risk and the eight sub-scores, without the raw Jev response
get_stats(): analyzed count and verdict split

MCP evaluations are archived like web ones, with source = 'mcp'.

Usage is tracked in the mcp_requests table: one row per JSON-RPC message with the method, tool name, client name and version (sent with initialize), user agent, protocol version, success or error, and latency. It never stores tool arguments or IP addresses. Summary for the last 7 days (or -- 30 for 30):

npm run mcp:usage

That report includes user agents and error messages, so it stays private. The public /stats/ page (stats/index.html + src/stats-page.tsx, linked in the footer) reads GET /api/usage (api/usage.ts, cached 5 minutes): ideas analyzed on the web and via MCP, a 30-day daily chart, tool calls, clients and verdicts. Client and tool names come from callers, so only known ones are published (clientLabel), everything else is "Other".

Docs: mcp/index.html is the static SEO page at /mcp/ (a second Vite entry); mcp/mcp.md is served as /mcp.md for agents and llms.txt is generated in vite.config.ts. Both are emitted at build time and served by the dev server.

claude mcp add --transport http killmyidea https://killmyidea.biz/api/mcp

nginx already proxies /api/ to the Node server, so no extra config is needed.

6. Scoring

src/lib/scoring.ts and src/lib/verdict.ts. That's all there is:

each question: Jev score 0–4 × 25 → 0–100
score = weighted average of the 8 questions (WEIGHTS)
Make money weights Real problem and Money twice; Open source replaces Money with Adoption; Just for fun replaces Real problem and Money with Immediate appeal and Fun. The two goal-defining questions always count twice. The API takes goal (money default, open_source, fun).
KILL below 50 · FIX 50–64 · SHIP 65+ (VERDICT_THRESHOLDS)
if understandability is below 0.3, the raw scores are retained for analysis but the UI asks for more detail instead of presenting a score or verdict
SCORING_VERSION identifies the exact questions, weights, thresholds and gating semantics

BEST SIGNAL / BIGGEST RISK are the highest / lowest question, with fixed copy in src/lib/copy.ts.

7. Jev questions

src/lib/questions.ts: Real problem, Clear customer, Demand, Money, Reach, Different, Buildable, Shareable, plus Adoption, Immediate appeal and Fun for goal-specific scoring. Each has five levels written as concrete situations (Jev judges each level on its own). The HTTP client is src/lib/typesafe.ts.

Layout

api/evaluate.ts           API endpoint for the website

api/mcp.ts MCP server (JSON-RPC over POST /api/mcp) api/_judge.ts shared pipeline (validate → Jev → score → archive) api/stats.ts API endpoint (ideas submitted + verdict split, 5-min cache) api/usage.ts public usage numbers for /stats/ (5-min cache) api/_analytics-db.ts SQLite archive for evaluation requests and scores api/_mock.ts local-only fake answers src/lib/questions.ts Jev questions src/lib/scoring.ts 0-4 → 0-100, average src/lib/verdict.ts KILL / FIX / SHIP thresholds src/lib/copy.ts fixed copy per question src/lib/storage.ts history (IdeaStore interface, localStorage implementation) src/lib/share.ts share text and X intent URL src/lib/features.ts public site and repository URLs src/components/ UI mcp/index.html /mcp/ docs page (SEO) mcp/mcp.md /mcp.md docs for agents stats/index.html /stats/ public usage page benchmarks/cases.json balanced, synthetic benchmark cases scripts/run-scoring-benchmark.mjs benchmark runner and summary

Analytics (DataFast, cookieless)

Production builds load DataFast's cookieless script (script.cookieless.js) with the site id dfid_UvVlC3fid8kOr95YTMIho (vite.config.ts). Dev builds only track when DATAFAST_WEBSITE_ID is set; DATAFAST_WEBSITE_ID=off disables tracking. DATAFAST_DOMAIN defaults to killmyidea.biz; DATAFAST_ALLOWED_HOSTNAMES defaults to killmyidea.stemonte.io so the old domain still counts during the move. In DataFast, enable Settings → General → Cookieless / privacy mode so the dashboard matches the script.

There is one custom goal (src/lib/analytics.ts): idea_submitted, with length, saved, and archived params. The idea text is never sent to DataFast.

Evaluation archive (SQLite)

Unless the user checks the opt-out, each successful evaluation creates one row in the evaluations table. It includes the idea, where it came from (source: web or mcp), scoring version, total score, raw verdict, clarity-gate status, category, all eight dimension scores, understandability, latency, model, token usage and the complete diagnostic response JSON. It deliberately excludes IP addresses, cookies and browser identifiers.

For example:

sqlite3 data/analytics.sqlite \

'SELECT scoring_version, goal, COUNT(*), ROUND(AVG(score), 1) FROM evaluations GROUP BY scoring_version, goal;'

Rows collected before scoring v2 are migrated without being reinterpreted: they remain scoring_version = 1, while v2 stores the new appeal score for fun ideas. To export:

sqlite3 -header -csv data/analytics.sqlite 'SELECT * FROM evaluations;' > evaluations.csv

Scoring benchmark

benchmarks/cases.json contains two similarly detailed, synthetic ideas for each category. The runner evaluates every case against all three goals and always sends doNotArchive: true. With the app running against Jev:

BENCHMARK_RUNS=3 npm run benchmark

It reports score and verdict distributions by goal, category accuracy, clarity gates and repeat-score range. The full JSON is written to the ignored benchmarks/results/latest.json; set BENCHMARK_URL to test a deployed instance.

.mcp.json registers the official DataFast MCP server (https://datafa.st/api/mcp). In Claude Code, run /mcp and sign in with OAuth to query these analytics.

Privacy

The public policy is privacy/index.html (/privacy/), with the terms in terms/index.html (/terms/). Keep them in step with what the code stores. Contact: hello@killmyidea.biz (Cloudflare Email Routing).

Private history is off by default and stays in the browser's localStorage. There are no accounts.
Successful evaluations are archived server-side for product analysis by default; the form provides an explicit opt-out.
DataFast never receives idea text. To move private history to Supabase, implement IdeaStore in src/lib/storage.ts.

License

MIT. See LICENSE.

Kill My Idea

Overview

PopNx MCP’s three pillars

What you can do with it

Install

Before you install

What it can do

Basic checksi

Maker matches the repo

Still maintained

Has a licence

Endpoint responds

Sign-in with OAuth

No hidden instructions in tool descriptions

Compared with others in Otheri

Common questions

Alternatives

Spec Driven Development

Remote Desktop Commander

Tethered Trust

README from the maker

Kill My Idea

1. Install

2. Environment

3. Run locally

4. Build

5. Deploy (Laravel Forge)

Domain move (killmyidea.stemonte.io → killmyidea.biz)

MCP server

6. Scoring

7. Jev questions

Layout

Analytics (DataFast, cookieless)

Evaluation archive (SQLite)

Scoring benchmark

Privacy

License