What it does
The why layer of repo-native project memory: the reasoning behind a codebase as Markdown in the repo, versioned by Git, for coding agents and humans, so nothing rejected is proposed twice. No database, no daemon, no account.
- Connects Instruction files the AI reads
- Account or key No key found in README or SKILL.md
- Category Coding
For makers: add a badge to your README
If you made this, paste this code into your README. The badge links back to this page.
[](https://mcp.popnx.com/en/skills/oliver-zehentleitner-keep-the-why)Use together with
MCP servers that connect the AI to services for the same work
Fallow
Codebase intelligence for TypeScript and JavaScript, exposed as structured MCP analysis tools.
Desktop Commander
MCP server for terminal commands, file operations, and process management
Similar Skills
Same kind of work, ordered like the Skills list
| This one keep-the-why | rea | andrej-karpathy-skills | graphify | MoneyPrinterTurbo | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Maker | oliver-zehentleitner | morluto | multica-ai | Graphify-Labs | harry0703 |
| Skills | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 |
| GitHub stars | 242 | 468,733 | 234,332 | 150,287 | 144,566 |
| Last code change | Nov 18, 2026 | Nov 19, 2026 | Apr 20, 2026 | Nov 18, 2026 | Nov 18, 2026 |
| License | MIT | MIT | – | Apache-2.0 | MIT |
1 skills (instruction sets) by oliver-zehentleitner that an AI reads and follows · not an MCP server
How a Skill differs from MCP
MCP = the hands
Connects the AI to an outside service or data, such as reading Notion or creating an invoice. A program or server has to be running.
Skill = the manual
A text file that teaches the AI how to do a task. It connects to nothing.
Some overlap: a few Skills run scripts that call tools, and a few MCP servers only send knowledge. Start from the task you want done.
Works with
Claude CodeCodexCursorGemini CLIGitHub CopilotOpenCode
From the maker’s README and the folders in the repo
Install
Is it safe?
- Who made it
GitHub account oliver-zehentleitner (person), 7 years old
- Use and upkeep
★ 242 stars, few users so far · code last changed Nov 18, 2026
- Any scripts?
No, plain text files the AI reads and follows
- Uses the internet?
No scripts, so it does not go online by itself
- Changes machine-wide settings?
No hooks or writes to machine settings found
Checked automatically from the repo files at commit 8fa9b76 (read only, nothing was run). Not a safety guarantee: read it and decide for yourself
First: which AI do you use?
Pick your app and this page shows only how to install it there
Option 1Upload to claude.ai (web and app)
Uploading to claude.ai would fail: the description is over 200 characters (576). Use "Let the AI install it" instead
Option 1Let Claude Code install it
Copy this sentence and paste it into a Claude Code chat
For one project, paste it into a chat that is open in that project’s folder · The AI always shows you the path before installing
The AI tells you what it will do first and asks your permission at every step
Restart Claude Code, then type /keep-the-why or ask for a matching task and Claude picks it up
Checked against official docs Nov 12, 2026 · Source: code.claude.com
For Terminal users
A Skill is instructions the AI will follow. Read the files before installing, and install only from makers you trust.
The maker’s recommended way
Install Node.js (if you don’t have it)
Already installed? Check first · Open Terminal, type this command and press Enter
node -v- A version number such as v26.13.1 = installed, skip this step
- "command not found" (on Windows: "is not recognized") = not installed yet, or installed but Terminal needs to be closed and reopened
How to open Terminal
Mac: press ⌘ + Space, type Terminal, press Enter
Windows: open Start, type Windows PowerShell, then Open
Not installed: Open the official download page, pick the LTS version and the click-through installer: .pkg on Mac · .msi on Windows. Double-click and follow it to the end. No curl command needed
Open the Node.js download page ↗
When it’s done, close Terminal, open it again and run the same command. You should see a version number: node -v
Install once; it works for everything that needs Node.js
The maker’s command is hidden · it does not install from this repo on GitHub · Commands hidden because they did not pass our check · install from the maker’s GitHub page instead
Copied from the maker’s README; it downloads and runs the maker’s code
Open Terminal
Mac: press Command+Space and type Terminal · Windows: the command below does not work in PowerShell; use “Let AI install it” above instead
Copy the skill folder to ~/.claude/skills
This downloads the repo to a temporary folder and copies only the folders that contain a SKILL.md
Checking the commands · copy buttons appear once they pass
Restart Claude Code, then type /keep-the-why or ask for a matching task and Claude picks it up
ChatGPT desktop app
The ChatGPT desktop app has Codex built in, and Codex reads skills from ~/.agents/skills
Option 1Let ChatGPT install it
Open Codex in the ChatGPT desktop app and paste this sentence into the chat
The AI always shows you the path before installing
The AI tells you what it will do first and asks your permission at every step
Option 2Put the folder there yourself
Put the keep-the-why folder at ~/.agents/skills/keep-the-why
~ is your home folder ($HOME)
For Terminal users
A Skill is instructions the AI will follow. Read the files before installing, and install only from makers you trust.
Open Terminal
Mac: press Command+Space and type Terminal · Windows: the command below does not work in PowerShell; use “Let AI install it” above instead
Copy the skill folder to ~/.agents/skills
This downloads the repo to a temporary folder and copies only the folders that contain a SKILL.md
Checking the commands · copy buttons appear once they pass
After installing
- ChatGPT desktop app: open Skills in the sidebar to see that the skill is there
- To use it: in ChatGPT type @ and pick the skill · in Codex CLI or the IDE extension run /skills or type $ and the skill name
- Codex picks up newly installed skills by itself; if one does not show up, restart Codex
Checked against official docs Nov 15, 2026 · Source: learn.chatgpt.com
ChatGPT on the web and mobile
Skills you install yourself do not work here; only skills that come with a plugin from the directory
To use this skill with ChatGPT, use the ChatGPT desktop app as above
Checked against official docs Nov 15, 2026 · Source: learn.chatgpt.com
Option 1Let Codex install it
Copy this sentence and paste it into a Codex chat · Works in Codex inside the ChatGPT desktop app, Codex CLI and the IDE extension
For one project, paste it into a chat that is open in that project’s folder · The AI always shows you the path before installing
The AI tells you what it will do first and asks your permission at every step
Codex picks up newly installed skills by itself; if one does not show up, restart Codex · To use it: in ChatGPT type @ and pick the skill · in Codex CLI or the IDE extension run /skills or type $ and the skill name
Checked against official docs Nov 15, 2026 · Source: learn.chatgpt.com
For Terminal users
A Skill is instructions the AI will follow. Read the files before installing, and install only from makers you trust.
Open Terminal
Mac: press Command+Space and type Terminal · Windows: the command below does not work in PowerShell; use “Let AI install it” above instead
Copy the skill folder to ~/.agents/skills
This downloads the repo to a temporary folder and copies only the folders that contain a SKILL.md
Checking the commands · copy buttons appear once they pass
Restart Codex, then ask for a matching task; Codex lists the skill
Option 1Let Cursor install it
Copy this sentence and paste it into a Cursor chat
For one project, paste it into a chat that is open in that project’s folder · The AI always shows you the path before installing
The AI tells you what it will do first and asks your permission at every step
In Cursor’s Agent chat, type / and pick keep-the-why
Checked against official docs Nov 12, 2026 · Source: cursor.com
For Terminal users
A Skill is instructions the AI will follow. Read the files before installing, and install only from makers you trust.
Open Terminal
Mac: press Command+Space and type Terminal · Windows: the command below does not work in PowerShell; use “Let AI install it” above instead
Copy the skill folder to ~/.cursor/skills
This downloads the repo to a temporary folder and copies only the folders that contain a SKILL.md
Checking the commands · copy buttons appear once they pass
In Cursor’s Agent chat, type / and pick keep-the-why
Option 1Let the AI install it
For other apps that read skills. The sentence gives the paths for Claude Code, Codex and Cursor so the AI picks the one for your app · Copy this sentence into the app’s chat
For one project, paste it into a chat that is open in that project’s folder · The AI always shows you the path before installing
The AI tells you what it will do first and asks your permission at every step
Checked against official docs Nov 12, 2026 · Source: code.claude.com, learn.chatgpt.com, cursor.com
For Terminal users
Other apps that support Agent Skills (such as Gemini CLI or GitHub Copilot) use different folders. Check that app’s guide, then copy the folder with the SKILL.md there.
Skill folders checked against the official Claude Code, Codex and Cursor guides on Nov 11, 2026
View the original SKILL.md
The text below comes from the maker’s repo, not from PopNx MCP
Showing the first 8,000 characters · Open the full file on GitHub
---
name: keep-the-why
description: In a project with a .keep-the-why, or when asked about Keep the Why or to set it up - extract and preserve the reasoning code cannot explain - decisions, rejected alternatives, workarounds, incidents, constraints - plus project setup and maintainer interviews. Not for what changed (see Keep a Changelog) - only why. Also the place for questions about how this skill works, complaints, feedback and settings changes about it. Anywhere else - no .keep-the-why, no such request - this skill is neither used nor offered nor named, not even in a closing offer to record something.
license: MIT
metadata:
version: "0.20.3"
repository: "https://github.com/oliver-zehentleitner/keep-the-why"
author: "Oliver Zehentleitner"
---
# Keep the Why
The core job: preserve and recover the reasoning that code alone cannot explain. Because "ask Bob" is not documentation — Keep a Changelog records what changed, this preserves why it changed.
## When to use this skill
Four modes, all part of the same job:
1. **Continuous capture** — record rationale as it surfaces during normal development: decisions, rejected alternatives, workarounds, incidents, constraints, and changes that *didn't* happen (starting to modify something, then stopping once a reason not to became clear — that reasoning would otherwise leave no trace). See `references/continuous-capture.md`.
2. **Retrospective recovery** — given an existing or legacy repository, reconstruct what the code cannot explain from git history, issues, existing docs, and the code itself. Before a pass, read `references/retrospective-analysis.md`.
3. **Knowledge-transfer interview** — when a maintainer's knowledge is about to become unavailable, analyze the repository first, then either ask targeted questions or let them narrate freely. Before preparing or running one, read `references/interview-playbook.md`.
4. **Maintenance** — keep existing rationale current: resolve contradictions, mark superseded entries, merge duplicates, split files that have grown too large.
Asked what Keep the Why is, how it works, or what one can ask for: before answering, read `references/help.md` — its parts (what is required, what optional), and the sentences that start each mode, setup, an update and each optional component.
## Edge cases
Don't create a `context/` entry for:
- Routine implementation detail with no rejected alternative behind it.
- Generic formatting or style changes.
- Anything already fully explained by the code itself.
- A correction — restoring something to what it should already have been (rule 4) — as opposed to a genuine fork between contending options.
Not every change is a decision worth a `context/` entry — see rule 10's proportionality gate.
## Composition with other skills
Keep the Why is a cross-cutting persistence skill, not a development methodology. When another skill governs *how* the work gets done (planning, debugging, TDD, code review), that workflow runs first; this skill only preserves the rationale it produces. A design doc or implementation plan is evidence to draw from, not something to duplicate (rule 3; "Which file does this belong in?" in `references/repository-structure.md`).
Re-check whether this skill applies at the natural end of another skill's workflow step (a design settled, a root cause confirmed, an alternative rejected) — that's when capture-worthy content has just been produced. This re-check isn't guaranteed to happen on its own — another framework can hold attention through its own workflow; asking directly ("check whether keep-the-why applies here") is a reasonable fallback, not a sign something's broken.
## Core rules
Rules 1 and 2 matter most — a skill that hallucinates rationale or acts on a misunderstood instruction is worse than no documentation.
1. **Never invent, never assume — ask.** If rationale can't be confirmed or reasonably inferred, mark it `unknown` or ask a focused question. This applies everywhere: entry content, config fields, ambiguous instructions, removals ("no reference found" means *unknown*, not *safe to delete* — ask before removing a Chesterton's Fence candidate; don't manufacture a justification either way). A genuinely *missing* config field with a documented default may be silently backfilled; a *present but unrecognized* or contradictory value is not the same — name the valid options and ask. Don't act on an unresolved ambiguity.
2. **Classify Evidence for every entry.** Three levels: **confirmed** (stated by a maintainer or backed by authoritative evidence), **inferred** (reasonably derived), **unknown** (can't be established). Evidence is a separate axis from Status (rule 5): a superseded decision can still have been confirmed when it was current. Add **Source** and **Verification** (`corroborated` | `uncorroborated` | `contradicted`) where there's something concrete to trace — a `contradicted` verification must explain what contradicts it. When two sources disagree, record both and flag the conflict as open rather than picking a winner. Full field definitions: `references/specification.md`; the `source-reference` setting governing when Source is actively sought: `references/setup.md`. One word per entry: when parts of an entry stand differently — a confirmed new reason beside a lost original one — the weakest grade wins and the body says which is which.
3. **Adapt to what exists.** Preserve the project's terminology and conventions. Update existing topic files instead of creating near-duplicates. Organize by *topic* (`auth.md`, `sync.md`), not by source file or commit. Existing, working decision records (an ADR folder, design notes) keep their own format: this skill's fields go on the entries it writes from now on, not retrofitted onto records that already work ("Retrofitting" in `references/repository-structure.md`).
4. **Record both halves of every decision: what was chosen, and what wasn't.** Actively look for rejected alternatives and why they lost — in code, history, and what the person said; if none surfaces, record that ("alternatives: unknown") and still write the entry; a follow-up question about alternatives goes on top, not instead. Only record alternatives that were genuinely in contention, not manufactured after the fact. A correction (fixing a stale value, a regressed bug) involved no real fork and belongs in `CHANGELOG.md`, not `context/` — its own line under the unreleased section, even when an older entry already names the restored value: that entry recorded the original change, not the regression's fix. Two sources that disagree — the code retries three times, the document says five — are not a correction until someone confirms which one is stale: neither is overwritten with the other, both are recorded and the conflict stays open (rule 2). Significance and decision-worthiness are different questions: rule 10 tests the former, this rule tests the latter.
5. **Track Status separately from Evidence.** Status values: `active`, `superseded`, `open`, `needs-review`, `pending-confirmation`. `open` means the question is unresolved (distinct from `Evidence: unknown`, which means a *settled* claim's rationale can't be traced). A retrospective finding with no traceable rationale becomes an entry with `Status: open` and `Evidence: unknown`, not only a remark (workflow step 5). Mark superseded entries explicitly instead of deleting them — `superseded` always comes with a `Superseded by` line naming the successor's `Id` (or `none — <why nothing replaced it>`). When a `Revisit when` condition (`references/specification.md`) triggers, flip Status to `needs-review` in that same turn — a mechanical edit needing no permission, not something to describe, propose, or defer. Resolving `needs-review` (whether to supersede, rewrite, or re-confirm) is a separate deliberate re-check that may need to ask (rule 8). Evidence stays as previously recorded until that re-check happens; the agent's own reading of the codDiscussion
Ask, share a tip or report that it does not work. Sorted by what people marked helpful.
No posts yet. Be the first to ask or share.
Posts here are written by users, not the PopNx team.
From GitHub
- GitHub stars
- 242
- Maker
- oliver-zehentleitner
- License
- MIT
- Last code change
- Nov 18, 2026
- SKILL.md files in the repo (including translated copies and templates)
- 1
- Topics
- agent-skills, ai-agents, architecture-decision-records, coding-agents, context-engineering, developer-tools, documentation, git, knowledge-management, llm-agents, project-memory, repo-local-memory