原型 · 预览版:收录官方注册中心里的全部服务器,每 30 分钟同步一次。使用 Google 登录即可撰写评价。原型 · 每 30 分钟更新
PopNx MCP为使用 AI 的人准备的 MCP 服务器 · 用大白话讲清楚

clarify-research-idea Skill

代码仓库 ↗

作者:cpt13-g★ 2981 个 skill

安装

What it does

Turn vague research directions into falsifiable, evidence-grounded Research Idea Briefs with a six-stage Codex workflow.

  • Connects Instruction files the AI reads
  • Account or key No key found in README or SKILL.md
  • Category 数据与研究
给作者:在 README 中加徽章

如果你是作者,可把这段代码贴到 README。徽章会链接回本页。

[![Featured on PopNx MCP](https://mcp.popnx.com/badge/skill/cpt13-g-clarify-research-idea.svg)](https://mcp.popnx.com/en/skills/cpt13-g-clarify-research-idea)

可搭配使用

在同一工作中把 AI 连到服务的 MCP

Firebase MCP

Gives AI development tools Firebase-specific capabilities and expertise.

作者:firebase广泛使用↓ 490.6万/周★ 4489 整个仓库的星标12个月前更新

MCP · 连接服务在你的电脑上运行✓ Brand-named GitHub · github.com/firebase

Supabase

MCP server for interacting with the Supabase platform

作者:supabase广泛使用↓ 24.6万/周★ 3018 整个仓库的星标昨天更新

MCP · 连接服务电脑或云端✓ 服务方 · supabase.com

Dbx

Query databases from AI agents using connections configured in DBX.

作者:t8y2广泛使用↓ 9446/周★ 3.1万7个月前更新

MCP · 连接服务在你的电脑上运行

相似的 Skill

同类工作,排序与 Skill 列表相同

与相似项目对比
本项
clarify-research-idea
timesfmShadowbrokergoogle-maps-scrapertradingview-mcp
作者cpt13-ggoogle-researchBigBodyCobaingosomatilaahmettaner
Skill 数11111
GitHub 星标29835,62911,6028,2095,307
最近代码更新2026年7月26日2026年11月13日2026年11月17日2026年11月15日2026年11月15日
许可证–Apache-2.0AGPL-3.0MITMIT

cpt13-g 提供的 1 个 Skill(指令集),AI 读取后照做 · 不是 MCP server

Skill 和 MCP 有什么不同

MCP = 手

把 AI 连到外部服务或数据,例如读取 Notion 或开发票。需要有程序或服务器在运行。

Skill = 手册

教 AI 怎么做某项工作的文本文件,不连接任何服务。

有些会重叠:少数 Skill 带有调用工具的脚本,少数 MCP 只提供知识。请从你想完成的工作出发。

适用的应用

Codex

依据开发者 README 和 repo 中的文件夹

安装

Is it safe?

  • Who made it

    GitHub account cpt13-g (person), 5 years old

  • Use and upkeep

    ★ 298 stars, few users so far · code last changed 2026年7月26日

  • Any scripts?

    No, plain text files the AI reads and follows

  • Uses the internet?

    No scripts, so it does not go online by itself

  • Changes machine-wide settings?

    No hooks or writes to machine settings found

Checked automatically from the repo files at commit 1f8334d (read only, nothing was run). Not a safety guarantee: read it and decide for yourself

第一步:你用哪个 AI?

选择你用的应用,本页只显示该应用的安装方法

Option 1Upload to claude.ai (web and app)

  1. Download from GitHub

    This skill has no license, so we do not hand out a ZIP from our site. Download it from GitHub and arrange the folder yourself, or use "Let the AI install it" above, which is easier

    Download from GitHub (whole repo) ↗

    Unzip it, then zip only the .agents/skills/clarify-research-idea folder again. The ZIP must have a clarify-research-idea folder with SKILL.md at the top level, no loose files

  2. Open Skills on claude.ai and upload

    +Create skillUpload a skillpick clarify-research-idea.zip

    Open claude.ai/customize/skills ↗

  3. No Upload button? Turn on file creation first

    SettingsCapabilitiesCode execution and file creation

    Turn on Code execution and file creation first (newer menus: Create and edit files) · personal plans: Settings → Capabilities · Team/Enterprise: an admin turns it on under Organization settings → Plugins & skills · every plan, including Free

Upload once; it works in claude.ai and Claude Desktop, and in recent Claude Code signed in with a Claude account (not with an API key)

Cowork and cloud sessions use the skills turned on in your claude.ai account, not ~/.claude/skills on your computer (Claude Desktop scheduled tasks run locally and still load it)

Checked against official docs 2026年11月12日 · Source: support.claude.com, support.claude.com, code.claude.com

Option 1让 Claude Code 帮你安装

复制这句话,粘贴到 Claude Code 的对话中

Where to install

已隐藏给 AI 的安装语句 · 目标位置与应用官方文档不符 · 命令未通过检查,已隐藏 · 请改从作者的 GitHub 页面安装

已隐藏给 AI 的安装语句 · 目标位置与应用官方文档不符 · 命令未通过检查,已隐藏 · 请改从作者的 GitHub 页面安装

For one project, paste it into a chat that is open in that project’s folder · The AI always shows you the path before installing

The AI tells you what it will do first and asks your permission at every step

重新打开 Claude Code,输入 /clarify-research-idea,或直接提出相关任务,Claude 会自动选用

Checked against official docs 2026年11月12日 · Source: code.claude.com

For Terminal users

Skill 是 AI 会照做的指令。安装前先阅读文件,只安装可信开发者的 Skill。

  1. 打开终端

    Mac:按 Command+空格输入 Terminal · Windows:下方命令在 PowerShell 中无法使用,请改用上方的“让 AI 帮你安装”

  2. 把 skill 文件夹复制到 ~/.claude/skills

    这条命令把 repo 下载到临时文件夹,只复制含 SKILL.md 的文件夹

    正在检查命令 · 通过后才会显示复制按钮

  3. 重新打开 Claude Code,输入 /clarify-research-idea,或直接提出相关任务,Claude 会自动选用

自己安装的 Skill 可用于 ChatGPT 桌面应用、Codex CLI 和 IDE 中的 Codex 扩展 · 网页版和手机版 ChatGPT 不能使用自己安装的 Skill,只能使用目录中插件自带的 Skill

ChatGPT 桌面应用

ChatGPT 桌面应用内置 Codex,Codex 从 ~/.agents/skills 文件夹读取 Skill

Option 1让 ChatGPT 帮你安装

在 ChatGPT 桌面应用中打开 Codex,把这句话粘贴到对话中

Where to install

已隐藏给 AI 的安装语句 · 目标位置与应用官方文档不符 · 命令未通过检查,已隐藏 · 请改从作者的 GitHub 页面安装

已隐藏给 AI 的安装语句 · 目标位置与应用官方文档不符 · 命令未通过检查,已隐藏 · 请改从作者的 GitHub 页面安装

The AI always shows you the path before installing

The AI tells you what it will do first and asks your permission at every step

Option 2自己放入文件夹

把 clarify-research-idea 文件夹放到 ~/.agents/skills/clarify-research-idea

~ 是你的主文件夹($HOME)

For Terminal users

Skill 是 AI 会照做的指令。安装前先阅读文件,只安装可信开发者的 Skill。

  1. 打开终端

    Mac:按 Command+空格输入 Terminal · Windows:下方命令在 PowerShell 中无法使用,请改用上方的“让 AI 帮你安装”

  2. 把 skill 文件夹复制到 ~/.agents/skills

    这条命令把 repo 下载到临时文件夹,只复制含 SKILL.md 的文件夹

    正在检查命令 · 通过后才会显示复制按钮

安装之后

  • ChatGPT 桌面应用:打开侧边栏中的 Skills,确认 Skill 已出现
  • 使用方法:在 ChatGPT 中输入 @ 并选择 Skill · 在 Codex CLI 或 IDE 扩展中运行 /skills,或输入 $ 加 Skill 名称
  • Codex 会自动发现新安装的 Skill;如果没有出现,请重启 Codex

Checked against official docs 2026年11月15日 · Source: learn.chatgpt.com

网页版和手机版 ChatGPT

不能使用你自己安装的 Skill,只能使用目录中插件自带的 Skill

想在 ChatGPT 中使用这个 Skill,请按上面的方法使用 ChatGPT 桌面应用

Checked against official docs 2026年11月15日 · Source: learn.chatgpt.com

Option 1让 Codex 帮你安装

复制这句话,粘贴到 Codex 的对话中 · 适用于 ChatGPT 桌面应用中的 Codex、Codex CLI 和 IDE 扩展

Where to install

已隐藏给 AI 的安装语句 · 目标位置与应用官方文档不符 · 命令未通过检查,已隐藏 · 请改从作者的 GitHub 页面安装

已隐藏给 AI 的安装语句 · 目标位置与应用官方文档不符 · 命令未通过检查,已隐藏 · 请改从作者的 GitHub 页面安装

For one project, paste it into a chat that is open in that project’s folder · The AI always shows you the path before installing

The AI tells you what it will do first and asks your permission at every step

Codex 会自动发现新安装的 Skill;如果没有出现,请重启 Codex · 使用方法:在 ChatGPT 中输入 @ 并选择 Skill · 在 Codex CLI 或 IDE 扩展中运行 /skills,或输入 $ 加 Skill 名称

Checked against official docs 2026年11月15日 · Source: learn.chatgpt.com

For Terminal users

Skill 是 AI 会照做的指令。安装前先阅读文件,只安装可信开发者的 Skill。

  1. 打开终端

    Mac:按 Command+空格输入 Terminal · Windows:下方命令在 PowerShell 中无法使用,请改用上方的“让 AI 帮你安装”

  2. 把 skill 文件夹复制到 ~/.agents/skills

    这条命令把 repo 下载到临时文件夹,只复制含 SKILL.md 的文件夹

    正在检查命令 · 通过后才会显示复制按钮

  3. 重新打开 Codex 并提出相关任务,Codex 会列出这个 skill

Option 1让 Cursor 帮你安装

复制这句话,粘贴到 Cursor 的对话中

Where to install

已隐藏给 AI 的安装语句 · 目标位置与应用官方文档不符 · 命令未通过检查,已隐藏 · 请改从作者的 GitHub 页面安装

已隐藏给 AI 的安装语句 · 目标位置与应用官方文档不符 · 命令未通过检查,已隐藏 · 请改从作者的 GitHub 页面安装

For one project, paste it into a chat that is open in that project’s folder · The AI always shows you the path before installing

The AI tells you what it will do first and asks your permission at every step

在 Cursor 的 Agent 聊天中输入 / 并选择 clarify-research-idea

Checked against official docs 2026年11月12日 · Source: cursor.com

For Terminal users

Skill 是 AI 会照做的指令。安装前先阅读文件,只安装可信开发者的 Skill。

  1. 打开终端

    Mac:按 Command+空格输入 Terminal · Windows:下方命令在 PowerShell 中无法使用,请改用上方的“让 AI 帮你安装”

  2. 把 skill 文件夹复制到 ~/.cursor/skills

    这条命令把 repo 下载到临时文件夹,只复制含 SKILL.md 的文件夹

    正在检查命令 · 通过后才会显示复制按钮

  3. 在 Cursor 的 Agent 聊天中输入 / 并选择 clarify-research-idea

Option 1Let the AI install it

适用于其他能读取 Skill 的应用。这句话列出了 Claude Code、Codex 和 Cursor 的路径,AI 会按你的应用选择 · Copy this sentence into the app’s chat

Where to install

已隐藏给 AI 的安装语句 · 目标位置与应用官方文档不符 · 命令未通过检查,已隐藏 · 请改从作者的 GitHub 页面安装

已隐藏给 AI 的安装语句 · 目标位置与应用官方文档不符 · 命令未通过检查,已隐藏 · 请改从作者的 GitHub 页面安装

For one project, paste it into a chat that is open in that project’s folder · The AI always shows you the path before installing

The AI tells you what it will do first and asks your permission at every step

Checked against official docs 2026年11月12日 · Source: code.claude.com, learn.chatgpt.com, cursor.com

For Terminal users

其他支持 Agent Skills 的应用(如 Gemini CLI、GitHub Copilot)使用不同文件夹,请查看该应用的指南,再把含 SKILL.md 的文件夹复制过去。

在 GitHub 上查看 ↗

已于 2026年11月11日 对照 Claude Code、Codex 和 Cursor 官方指南核实 skill 文件夹

查看原始 SKILL.md

以下文字来自开发者的 repo,不是 PopNx MCP 的指令

显示前 8,000 个字符 · 在 GitHub 打开完整文件

---
name: clarify-research-idea
description: Turn vague or partially formed AI, computer-science, data-driven, and engineering-method research directions into evidence-grounded, falsifiable, paper-ready Research Idea Briefs through heuristic questioning, staged confirmation, literature positioning, novelty attack, and method-figure planning. Use when the user needs to clarify a research idea, formalize inputs/outputs/objectives/constraints, frame background and motivation, select 3-5 anchor papers, identify a defensible gap, derive 2-3 contributions, stress-test novelty, or design an input-to-output method framework and core-paper figure. Also trigger on requests such as 明确科研 idea、启发式梳理 idea、互动追问科研问题、梳理论文创新点、定义研究任务、找对标论文、把研究方向变成论文方案、画方法框架图. Do not use as the primary workflow for running experiments, exhaustive systematic reviews, drafting full manuscript sections, or polishing finished prose.
---

# Clarify Research Idea

Convert an early research direction into an auditable idea architecture before detailed experiment design or manuscript writing. Preserve the researcher's judgment: make assumptions and framing visible, challenge weak novelty, and never manufacture supporting evidence.

## Choose the operating mode

Use `guided` by default when the question, gap, or method is uncertain. Ask one high-information question at a time, maintain a visible working draft, and pause at the three checkpoints.

Use `synthesize` when the user supplies enough material or explicitly requests a one-pass result. Complete the brief with labeled assumptions; mark checkpoint-dependent claims `UNCONFIRMED` and request confirmation at the end.

State the selected mode, research domain, maturity level, and intended deliverable in one short line. Let the user correct them cheaply.

## Run the heuristic interaction loop

Read [interactive-heuristics.md](references/interactive-heuristics.md) in `guided` mode, whenever the user's idea is vague, or whenever the user asks for interactive clarification. Treat interaction as part of the method, not as casual clarification.

Use this turn pattern:

1. State the current bottleneck in one sentence.
2. Ask one high-information question that will change the idea architecture.
3. Offer 2-3 plausible answer directions when the user is unsure.
4. Update the visible `Working Idea Canvas` with provenance labels before asking the next question.

Do not overwhelm the user with a survey. If multiple questions are useful, choose the one that best constrains the task, gap, hypothesis, or evidence path. If the user asks for a fast one-pass result, switch to `synthesize` and mark unconfirmed decisions explicitly.

## Maintain provenance

Label substantive content throughout the workflow:

- `PROVIDED`: stated or supplied by the user.
- `VERIFIED`: supported by a checked primary source or supplied artifact.
- `INFERRED`: reasoned from available material but not directly established.
- `PROVISIONAL`: useful working hypothesis awaiting evidence or user confirmation.
- `UNKNOWN`: missing and consequential.

Do not silently upgrade one status to another. When browsing or academic-search tools are available, verify time-sensitive literature claims and bibliographic metadata. Treat failure to find a paper as search incompleteness, not proof of novelty.

## Run the workflow

### 0. Scope the session

Determine the application, research object, current idea, intended venue or audience, available data or system, resource limits, and desired output language. Stay centered on AI, computer science, data-driven science, and engineering-method papers. If the request is primarily qualitative or non-methodological, explain that the mathematical contract must be adapted before continuing.

Identify whether the user has: a broad interest, a question without a task definition, a method without positioning, anchor papers without a gap, or a nearly complete idea needing audit. Use the maturity triage in [interactive-heuristics.md](references/interactive-heuristics.md) to choose the first question. Reuse supplied documents and prior decisions instead of re-asking settled questions.

### 1. Establish the Task Contract

Read [task-formalization.md](references/task-formalization.md). Define the inference-time inputs, required outputs, data or interaction process, model or decision function, objective, constraints, evaluation measures, baselines, assumptions, and explicit exclusions. Use mathematical notation only when it removes ambiguity; do not invent a loss function for appearance.

Require alignment among the claimed problem, information available at use time, optimization target, and evaluation metric.

**Checkpoint 1 — Task Contract:** Present the one-sentence task, compact formulation, success criterion, assumptions, and scope boundaries. In `guided` mode, obtain user confirmation before treating the contract as fixed.

### 2. Make the argument and framing explicit

Read [framing-and-motivation.md](references/framing-and-motivation.md). Build the chain:

`background -> consequential friction -> unresolved cause -> required capability -> proposed research move`

Record the intended reader update, the current default view, and the strongest counter-position in a `Framing Intent` block. Allow framing to guide emphasis and argument order, but never let it bias evidence retrieval, omit material counterevidence, or turn a hypothesis into a fact.

Express each challenge as a causal requirement, not an adjective: property of the setting -> technical difficulty -> why generic methods fail -> capability the solution must provide.

### 3. Position against 3-5 anchor papers

Read [anchor-paper-positioning.md](references/anchor-paper-positioning.md). Select papers by role rather than fame: problem anchor, method anchor, closest competitor, experiment anchor, and optional writing/architecture anchor. A paper may fill more than one role.

Verify title, authors, year, venue or repository, and DOI or stable URL. Extract `WHY / HOW / WHAT / LIMIT / TRANSFER` for each paper. Compare task assumptions and evidence, not only module names. Derive high-level writing characteristics without copying distinctive wording.

### 4. Derive and attack the idea

Read [novelty-and-falsification.md](references/novelty-and-falsification.md). Consider three routes: a genuinely new problem, an old problem with an ignored condition or failure mode, or new evidence/understanding that changes a boundary. Force each candidate through:

`observed gap -> underlying cause -> design principle -> method component -> expected evidence`

Generate alternatives only when they help the user choose. Reduce the selected idea to one core hypothesis and 2-3 contribution cards. Attack it with the closest existing method, the simplest plausible baseline, alternative explanations, confounds, negative cases, and feasibility limits. In `guided` mode, run the reviewer-simulation questions from [interactive-heuristics.md](references/interactive-heuristics.md) before treating a contribution as stable.

**Checkpoint 2 — Positioning and Hypothesis:** Present the verified anchors, defensible gap, rejected alternatives, core hypothesis, and falsifier. In `guided` mode, obtain user confirmation before freezing the method architecture.

### 5. Design the method architecture and core figure

Read [framework-figure.md](references/framework-figure.md). Map every challenge to a design principle, every principle to a component or procedure, and every component to a claim and validation hook. Build an editable textual specification and a Mermaid draft using:

`context/input -> problem structure -> method components -> objective/constraints -> output -> evidence`

Keep the figure causal and selective. Do not add decorative modules merely to make the method look complex. If the user requests an actual `.pptx`, hand the approved figure specification to a presentation-generation workflow rather than making PowerPoint a hidden dependency of 

讨论

提问、分享技巧或报告无法使用。按“有帮助”数量排序。

还没有帖子,欢迎第一个提问或分享。

此处内容由用户撰写,不代表 PopNx 团队。

登录后发帖

来自 GitHub

GitHub 星标
298
开发者
cpt13-g
许可证
未注明许可证 此 repo 未注明许可证,默认作者保留所有权利;转发或商用前请先询问作者。
最近代码更新
2026年7月26日
repo 中的 SKILL.md 文件(含译本和模板)
1
主题
academic-research, ai-research, codex, codex-skills, research-idea, research-workflow, scientific-method