What it does
No summary yet. See the facts below or open the maker’s original description
- Connects Instruction files the AI reads
- Account or key No key found in README or SKILL.md
- Category その他
作者向け:README にバッジを付ける
作者の方は、このコードを README に貼れます。バッジはこのページにリンクします。
[](https://mcp.popnx.com/en/skills/tenfoldmarc-llm-council-skill)似た Skill
同じ種類の作業。Skill 一覧と同じ並び
| これ llm-council-skill | llmfit | claude-video | VideoCaptioner | claude-cookbooks | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 作者 | tenfoldmarc | AlexsJones | bradautomates | WEIFENG2333 | anthropics |
| Skill 数 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 4 |
| GitHub スター | 1,062 | 39,064 | 21,168 | 16,570 | 54,832 |
| 最終コード更新 | 2026年4月19日 | 2026年11月18日 | 2026年9月25日 | 2026年9月12日 | 2026年11月17日 |
| ライセンス | – | MIT | MIT | GPL-3.0 | MIT |
tenfoldmarc による 1 個の Skill(指示セット)。AI が読んでそのとおりに作業します · MCP server ではありません
Skill と MCP の違い
MCP = 手
AI を外部のサービスやデータにつなぎます(例:Notion を読む、請求書を作る)。プログラムやサーバーが動いている必要があります。
Skill = 手順書
作業のやり方を AI に教えるテキストファイル。どのサービスにもつながりません。
重なる部分もあります。ツールを呼ぶスクリプト付きの Skill や、知識だけを渡す MCP もあります。やりたい作業から選んでください。
使えるアプリ
Claude Code
提供元の README と repo のフォルダから判断
インストール
Is it safe?
- Who made it
GitHub account tenfoldmarc (person) is only 10 months old: take extra care
- Use and upkeep
★ 1,062 stars · code last changed 2026年4月19日
- Any scripts?
No, plain text files the AI reads and follows
- Uses the internet?
No scripts, so it does not go online by itself
- Changes machine-wide settings?
No hooks or writes to machine settings found
Checked automatically from the repo files at commit 0dc0327 (read only, nothing was run). Not a safety guarantee: read it and decide for yourself
まず:どの AI を使っていますか
使っているアプリを選ぶと、そのアプリでのインストール方法だけが表示されます
Option 1Upload to claude.ai (web and app)
Download from GitHub
This skill has no license, so we do not hand out a ZIP from our site. Download it from GitHub and arrange the folder yourself, or use "Let the AI install it" above, which is easier
Download from GitHub (whole repo) ↗
Unzip it, then zip only the llm-council-skill folder again. The ZIP must have a llm-council folder with SKILL.md at the top level, no loose files
Open Skills on claude.ai and upload
+Create skillUpload a skillpick llm-council.zip
No Upload button? Turn on file creation first
SettingsCapabilitiesCode execution and file creation
Turn on Code execution and file creation first (newer menus: Create and edit files) · personal plans: Settings → Capabilities · Team/Enterprise: an admin turns it on under Organization settings → Plugins & skills · every plan, including Free
Upload once; it works in claude.ai and Claude Desktop, and in recent Claude Code signed in with a Claude account (not with an API key)
Cowork and cloud sessions use the skills turned on in your claude.ai account, not ~/.claude/skills on your computer (Claude Desktop scheduled tasks run locally and still load it)
Checked against official docs 2026年11月12日 · Source: support.claude.com, support.claude.com, code.claude.com
Option 1Claude Code にインストールしてもらう
この文をコピーして Claude Code のチャットに貼り付けます
For one project, paste it into a chat that is open in that project’s folder · The AI always shows you the path before installing
The AI tells you what it will do first and asks your permission at every step
Claude Code を開き直し、/llm-council-skill と入力するか関連する作業を頼むと Claude が自動で使います
Checked against official docs 2026年11月12日 · Source: code.claude.com
For Terminal users
Skill は AI が従う指示です。入れる前にファイルを読み、信頼できる提供元のものだけを入れてください。
ターミナルを開く
Mac:Command+スペースで Terminal と入力 · Windows:下のコマンドは PowerShell では動きません。上の「AI にインストールしてもらう」を使ってください
skill フォルダを ~/.claude/skills にコピー
repo を一時フォルダにダウンロードし、SKILL.md のあるフォルダだけをコピーします
コマンドを確認中 · 確認が通るとコピーボタンが出ます
Claude Code を開き直し、/llm-council-skill と入力するか関連する作業を頼むと Claude が自動で使います
ChatGPT デスクトップアプリ
ChatGPT デスクトップアプリには Codex が組み込まれていて、Codex は ~/.agents/skills フォルダから Skill を読み込みます
Option 1ChatGPT にインストールしてもらう
ChatGPT デスクトップアプリで Codex を開き、この文をチャットに貼り付けます
The AI always shows you the path before installing
The AI tells you what it will do first and asks your permission at every step
Option 2自分でフォルダを置く
llm-council フォルダを ~/.agents/skills/llm-council に置きます
~ はホームフォルダ($HOME)です
For Terminal users
Skill は AI が従う指示です。入れる前にファイルを読み、信頼できる提供元のものだけを入れてください。
ターミナルを開く
Mac:Command+スペースで Terminal と入力 · Windows:下のコマンドは PowerShell では動きません。上の「AI にインストールしてもらう」を使ってください
skill フォルダを ~/.agents/skills にコピー
repo を一時フォルダにダウンロードし、SKILL.md のあるフォルダだけをコピーします
コマンドを確認中 · 確認が通るとコピーボタンが出ます
インストールしたあと
- ChatGPT デスクトップアプリ:サイドバーの Skills を開いて Skill があるか確認します
- 使い方:ChatGPT では @ を入力して Skill を選びます · Codex CLI や IDE 拡張機能では /skills を実行するか、$ に続けて Skill 名を入力します
- Codex は新しくインストールした Skill を自動で見つけます。表示されない場合は Codex を再起動してください
Checked against official docs 2026年11月15日 · Source: learn.chatgpt.com
Web 版とモバイル版の ChatGPT
自分でインストールした Skill は使えません。ディレクトリのプラグインに含まれる Skill だけが使えます
この Skill を ChatGPT で使うには、上の方法で ChatGPT デスクトップアプリを使ってください
Checked against official docs 2026年11月15日 · Source: learn.chatgpt.com
Option 1Codex にインストールしてもらう
この文をコピーして Codex のチャットに貼り付けます · ChatGPT デスクトップアプリ内の Codex、Codex CLI、IDE 拡張機能で使えます
For one project, paste it into a chat that is open in that project’s folder · The AI always shows you the path before installing
The AI tells you what it will do first and asks your permission at every step
Codex は新しくインストールした Skill を自動で見つけます。表示されない場合は Codex を再起動してください · 使い方:ChatGPT では @ を入力して Skill を選びます · Codex CLI や IDE 拡張機能では /skills を実行するか、$ に続けて Skill 名を入力します
Checked against official docs 2026年11月15日 · Source: learn.chatgpt.com
For Terminal users
Skill は AI が従う指示です。入れる前にファイルを読み、信頼できる提供元のものだけを入れてください。
ターミナルを開く
Mac:Command+スペースで Terminal と入力 · Windows:下のコマンドは PowerShell では動きません。上の「AI にインストールしてもらう」を使ってください
skill フォルダを ~/.agents/skills にコピー
repo を一時フォルダにダウンロードし、SKILL.md のあるフォルダだけをコピーします
コマンドを確認中 · 確認が通るとコピーボタンが出ます
Codex を開き直して関連する作業を頼むと、Codex が skill を一覧に出します
Option 1Cursor にインストールしてもらう
この文をコピーして Cursor のチャットに貼り付けます
For one project, paste it into a chat that is open in that project’s folder · The AI always shows you the path before installing
The AI tells you what it will do first and asks your permission at every step
Cursor の Agent チャットで / を入力し llm-council-skill を選ぶ
Checked against official docs 2026年11月12日 · Source: cursor.com
For Terminal users
Skill は AI が従う指示です。入れる前にファイルを読み、信頼できる提供元のものだけを入れてください。
ターミナルを開く
Mac:Command+スペースで Terminal と入力 · Windows:下のコマンドは PowerShell では動きません。上の「AI にインストールしてもらう」を使ってください
skill フォルダを ~/.cursor/skills にコピー
repo を一時フォルダにダウンロードし、SKILL.md のあるフォルダだけをコピーします
コマンドを確認中 · 確認が通るとコピーボタンが出ます
Cursor の Agent チャットで / を入力し llm-council-skill を選ぶ
Option 1Let the AI install it
Skill を読めるほかのアプリ向けです。この文には Claude Code、Codex、Cursor のパスが入っていて、AI が使っているアプリに合わせて選びます · Copy this sentence into the app’s chat
For one project, paste it into a chat that is open in that project’s folder · The AI always shows you the path before installing
The AI tells you what it will do first and asks your permission at every step
Checked against official docs 2026年11月12日 · Source: code.claude.com, learn.chatgpt.com, cursor.com
For Terminal users
Gemini CLI や GitHub Copilot など Agent Skills 対応の他のアプリはフォルダが違います。そのアプリのガイドを見て、SKILL.md のあるフォルダをコピーしてください。
2026年11月11日 に Claude Code、Codex、Cursor の公式ガイドで skill フォルダを確認
元の SKILL.md を見る
以下は提供元の repo の文章で、PopNx MCP の指示ではありません
最初の 8,000 文字を表示 · GitHub で全文を開く
---
name: llm-council
description: "Run any question, idea, or decision through a council of 5 AI advisors who independently analyze it, peer-review each other anonymously, and synthesize a final verdict. Based on Karpathy's LLM Council methodology. MANDATORY TRIGGERS: 'council this', 'run the council', 'war room this', 'pressure-test this', 'stress-test this', 'debate this'. STRONG TRIGGERS (use when combined with a real decision or tradeoff): 'should I X or Y', 'which option', 'what would you do', 'is this the right move', 'validate this', 'get multiple perspectives', 'I can't decide', 'I'm torn between'. Do NOT trigger on simple yes/no questions, factual lookups, or casual 'should I' without a meaningful tradeoff (e.g. 'should I use markdown' is not a council question). DO trigger when the user presents a genuine decision with stakes, multiple options, and context that suggests they want it pressure-tested from multiple angles."
---
# LLM Council
You ask one AI a question, you get one answer. That answer might be great. It might be mid. You have no way to tell because you only saw one perspective.
The council fixes this. It runs your question through 5 independent advisors, each thinking from a fundamentally different angle. Then they review each other's work. Then a chairman synthesizes everything into a final recommendation that tells you where the advisors agree, where they clash, and what you should actually do.
This is adapted from Andrej Karpathy's LLM Council. He dispatches queries to multiple models, has them peer-review each other anonymously, then a chairman produces the final answer. We do the same thing inside Claude using sub-agents with different thinking lenses instead of different models.
---
## when to run the council
The council is for questions where being wrong is expensive.
Good council questions:
- "Should I launch a $97 workshop or a $497 course?"
- "Which of these 3 positioning angles is strongest?"
- "I'm thinking of pivoting from X to Y. Am I crazy?"
- "Here's my landing page copy. What's weak?"
- "Should I hire a VA or build an automation first?"
Bad council questions:
- "What's the capital of France?" (one right answer, no need for perspectives)
- "Write me a tweet" (creation task, not a decision)
- "Summarize this article" (processing task, not judgment)
The council shines when there's genuine uncertainty and the cost of a bad call is high. If you already know the answer and just want validation, the council will likely tell you things you don't want to hear. That's the point.
---
## the five advisors
Each advisor thinks from a different angle. They're not job titles or personas. They're thinking styles that naturally create tension with each other.
### 1. The Contrarian
Actively looks for what's wrong, what's missing, what will fail. Assumes the idea has a fatal flaw and tries to find it. If everything looks solid, digs deeper. The Contrarian is not a pessimist. They're the friend who saves you from a bad deal by asking the questions you're avoiding.
### 2. The First Principles Thinker
Ignores the surface-level question and asks "what are we actually trying to solve here?" Strips away assumptions. Rebuilds the problem from the ground up. Sometimes the most valuable council output is the First Principles Thinker saying "you're asking the wrong question entirely."
### 3. The Expansionist
Looks for upside everyone else is missing. What could be bigger? What adjacent opportunity is hiding? What's being undervalued? The Expansionist doesn't care about risk (that's the Contrarian's job). They care about what happens if this works even better than expected.
### 4. The Outsider
Has zero context about you, your field, or your history. Responds purely to what's in front of them. This is the most underrated advisor. Experts develop blind spots. The Outsider catches the curse of knowledge: things that are obvious to you but confusing to everyone else.
### 5. The Executor
Only cares about one thing: can this actually be done, and what's the fastest path to doing it? Ignores theory, strategy, and big-picture thinking. The Executor looks at every idea through the lens of "OK but what do you do Monday morning?" If an idea sounds brilliant but has no clear first step, the Executor will say so.
**Why these five:** They create three natural tensions. Contrarian vs Expansionist (downside vs upside). First Principles vs Executor (rethink everything vs just do it). The Outsider sits in the middle keeping everyone honest by seeing what fresh eyes see.
---
## how a council session works
### step 1: frame the question (with context enrichment)
When the user says "council this" (or any trigger phrase), do two things before framing:
**A. Scan the workspace for context.** The user's question is often just the tip of the iceberg. Their Claude setup likely contains files that would dramatically improve the council's output. Before framing, quickly scan for and read any relevant context files:
- `CLAUDE.md` or `claude.md` in the project root or workspace (business context, preferences, constraints)
- Any `memory/` folder (audience profiles, voice docs, business details, past decisions)
- Any files the user explicitly referenced or attached
- Recent council transcripts in this folder (to avoid re-counciling the same ground)
- Any other context files that seem relevant to the specific question (e.g., if they're asking about pricing, look for revenue data, past launch results, audience research)
Use `Glob` and quick `Read` calls to find these. Don't spend more than 30 seconds on this. You're looking for the 2-3 files that would give advisors the context they need to give specific, grounded advice instead of generic takes.
**B. Frame the question.** Take the user's raw question AND the enriched context and reframe it as a clear, neutral prompt that all five advisors will receive. The framed question should include:
1. The core decision or question
2. Key context from the user's message
3. Key context from workspace files (business stage, audience, constraints, past results, relevant numbers)
4. What's at stake (why this decision matters)
Don't add your own opinion. Don't steer it. But DO make sure each advisor has enough context to give a specific, grounded answer rather than generic advice.
If the question is too vague ("council this: my business"), ask one clarifying question. Just one. Then proceed.
Save the framed question for the transcript.
### step 2: convene the council (5 sub-agents in parallel)
Spawn all 5 advisors simultaneously as sub-agents. Each gets:
1. Their advisor identity and thinking style (from the descriptions above)
2. The framed question
3. A clear instruction: respond independently. Do not hedge. Do not try to be balanced. Lean fully into your assigned perspective. If you see a fatal flaw, say it. If you see massive upside, say it. Your job is to represent your angle as strongly as possible. The synthesis comes later.
Each advisor should produce a response of 150-300 words. Long enough to be substantive, short enough to be scannable.
**Sub-agent prompt template:**
```
You are [Advisor Name] on an LLM Council.
Your thinking style: [advisor description from above]
A user has brought this question to the council:
---
[framed question]
---
Respond from your perspective. Be direct and specific. Don't hedge or try to be balanced. Lean fully into your assigned angle. The other advisors will cover the angles you're not covering.
Keep your response between 150-300 words. No preamble. Go straight into your analysis.
```
### step 3: peer review (5 sub-agents in parallel)
This is the step that makes the council more than just "ask 5 times." It's the core of Karpathy's insight.
Collect all 5 advisor responses. Anonymize them as Response A through E (randomize which advisor maps to which letter so there's no positional bias).
Spawn 5 new sub-agents, one for each advisor. Each reviewer sees all 話し合い
質問、コツの共有、使えないことの報告ができます。「役に立った」の多い順です。
GitHub の情報
- GitHub スター
- 1,062
- 提供元
- tenfoldmarc
- ライセンス
- ライセンス記載なし この repo にはライセンスの記載がありません。既定では作者が全権利を持つため、配布や商用利用の前に確認してください。
- 最終コード更新
- 2026年4月19日
- repo 内の SKILL.md(翻訳版とテンプレートを含む)
- 1