REA
Reverse engineer anything from your terminal or agent with one CLI and MCP server.
A portable project-planning skill for Codex, Claude Code, pi, Hermes, and Agent Skills-compatible harnesses. Evidence before build advice.
제작자라면 이 코드를 README에 붙여 넣으세요. 배지는 이 페이지로 연결됩니다.
[](https://mcp.popnx.com/en/skills/aaravkashyap12-advise-project-approach)같은 작업에서 AI를 서비스에 연결하는 MCP
Reverse engineer anything from your terminal or agent with one CLI and MCP server.
Codebase intelligence for TypeScript and JavaScript, exposed as structured MCP analysis tools.
MCP server for terminal commands, file operations, and process management
같은 종류의 작업, Skill 목록과 같은 순서
| 이 항목 advise-project-approach | rea | andrej-karpathy-skills | graphify | MoneyPrinterTurbo | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 제작자 | AaravKashyap12 | morluto | multica-ai | Graphify-Labs | harry0703 |
| Skill 수 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 |
| GitHub 별 | 330 | 468,733 | 234,332 | 150,287 | 144,566 |
| 마지막 코드 변경 | 2026년 8월 31일 | 2026년 11월 19일 | 2026년 4월 20일 | 2026년 11월 18일 | 2026년 11월 18일 |
| 라이선스 | MIT | MIT | – | Apache-2.0 | MIT |
AaravKashyap12의 Skill(지시 묶음) 1개, AI가 읽고 그대로 일해요 · MCP server가 아니에요
MCP = 손
AI를 외부 서비스나 데이터에 연결합니다(예: Notion 읽기, 청구서 만들기). 프로그램이나 서버가 실행 중이어야 합니다.
Skill = 안내서
작업 방법을 AI에게 가르치는 텍스트 파일. 어떤 서비스에도 연결되지 않습니다.
겹치는 경우도 있습니다. 도구를 부르는 스크립트가 있는 Skill도, 지식만 보내는 MCP도 있습니다. 하려는 작업을 기준으로 고르세요.
Claude CodeCodex
제작자 README와 repo 폴더 기준
GitHub account AaravKashyap12 (person), 3 years old
★ 330 stars, few users so far · code last changed 2026년 8월 31일
No, plain text files the AI reads and follows
No scripts, so it does not go online by itself
No hooks or writes to machine settings found
Checked automatically from the repo files at commit abdde26 (read only, nothing was run). Not a safety guarantee: read it and decide for yourself
먼저: 어떤 AI를 쓰시나요
쓰는 앱을 고르면 그 앱의 설치 방법만 보여 드립니다
Uploading to claude.ai would fail: the description is over 200 characters (634). Use "Let the AI install it" instead
이 문장을 복사해 Claude Code 채팅에 붙여 넣으세요
For one project, paste it into a chat that is open in that project’s folder · The AI always shows you the path before installing
The AI tells you what it will do first and asks your permission at every step
Claude Code를 다시 열고 /advise-project-approach를 입력하거나 관련 작업을 요청하면 Claude가 알아서 써요
Checked against official docs 2026년 11월 12일 · Source: code.claude.com
Skill은 AI가 따르는 지시예요. 설치 전에 파일을 읽고, 믿을 수 있는 제작자 것만 설치하세요.
이미 설치했나요? 먼저 확인 · 터미널을 열고 이 명령을 입력한 뒤 Enter
node -vMac: ⌘ + Space를 누르고 Terminal 입력 후 Enter
Windows: 시작 메뉴를 열고 Windows PowerShell 입력 후 "열기"
아직 설치하지 않았다면: 공식 다운로드 페이지에서 LTS 버전과 클릭형 설치 파일을 고르세요: Mac은 .pkg · Windows는 .msi. 더블클릭 후 끝까지 진행하면 됩니다. curl 명령은 필요 없습니다
설치가 끝나면 터미널을 닫았다가 다시 열고 같은 명령을 실행하세요. 버전 번호가 나와야 합니다: node -v
한 번 설치하면 Node.js가 필요한 모든 도구에서 쓸 수 있습니다
명령을 확인하는 중 · 확인을 통과하면 복사 버튼이 나타나요
제작자 README에서 가져온 명령으로, 제작자 코드를 내려받아 실행해요
Mac: Command+스페이스 후 Terminal 입력 · Windows: 아래 명령은 PowerShell에서 안 돼요. 위의 “AI에게 설치 맡기기”를 쓰세요
repo를 임시 폴더에 내려받고 SKILL.md가 있는 폴더만 복사해요
명령을 확인하는 중 · 확인을 통과하면 복사 버튼이 나타나요
ChatGPT 데스크톱 앱에는 Codex가 들어 있고, Codex는 ~/.agents/skills 폴더에서 Skill을 읽습니다
ChatGPT 데스크톱 앱에서 Codex를 열고 이 문장을 채팅에 붙여 넣으세요
The AI always shows you the path before installing
The AI tells you what it will do first and asks your permission at every step
advise-project-approach 폴더를 ~/.agents/skills/advise-project-approach에 넣으세요
~는 홈 폴더($HOME)입니다
Skill은 AI가 따르는 지시예요. 설치 전에 파일을 읽고, 믿을 수 있는 제작자 것만 설치하세요.
Mac: Command+스페이스 후 Terminal 입력 · Windows: 아래 명령은 PowerShell에서 안 돼요. 위의 “AI에게 설치 맡기기”를 쓰세요
repo를 임시 폴더에 내려받고 SKILL.md가 있는 폴더만 복사해요
명령을 확인하는 중 · 확인을 통과하면 복사 버튼이 나타나요
Checked against official docs 2026년 11월 15일 · Source: learn.chatgpt.com
직접 설치한 Skill은 쓸 수 없고, 디렉터리의 플러그인에 들어 있는 Skill만 쓸 수 있습니다
이 Skill을 ChatGPT에서 쓰려면 위 방법대로 ChatGPT 데스크톱 앱을 쓰세요
Checked against official docs 2026년 11월 15일 · Source: learn.chatgpt.com
이 문장을 복사해 Codex 채팅에 붙여 넣으세요 · ChatGPT 데스크톱 앱 안의 Codex, Codex CLI, IDE 확장 프로그램에서 모두 쓸 수 있습니다
For one project, paste it into a chat that is open in that project’s folder · The AI always shows you the path before installing
The AI tells you what it will do first and asks your permission at every step
Codex는 새로 설치한 Skill을 스스로 찾습니다. 보이지 않으면 Codex를 다시 시작하세요 · 쓰는 법: ChatGPT에서는 @를 입력하고 Skill을 고르세요 · Codex CLI나 IDE 확장 프로그램에서는 /skills를 실행하거나 $ 뒤에 Skill 이름을 입력하세요
Checked against official docs 2026년 11월 15일 · Source: learn.chatgpt.com
Skill은 AI가 따르는 지시예요. 설치 전에 파일을 읽고, 믿을 수 있는 제작자 것만 설치하세요.
Mac: Command+스페이스 후 Terminal 입력 · Windows: 아래 명령은 PowerShell에서 안 돼요. 위의 “AI에게 설치 맡기기”를 쓰세요
repo를 임시 폴더에 내려받고 SKILL.md가 있는 폴더만 복사해요
명령을 확인하는 중 · 확인을 통과하면 복사 버튼이 나타나요
이 문장을 복사해 Cursor 채팅에 붙여 넣으세요
For one project, paste it into a chat that is open in that project’s folder · The AI always shows you the path before installing
The AI tells you what it will do first and asks your permission at every step
Cursor Agent 채팅에서 /를 입력하고 advise-project-approach 선택
Checked against official docs 2026년 11월 12일 · Source: cursor.com
Skill은 AI가 따르는 지시예요. 설치 전에 파일을 읽고, 믿을 수 있는 제작자 것만 설치하세요.
Mac: Command+스페이스 후 Terminal 입력 · Windows: 아래 명령은 PowerShell에서 안 돼요. 위의 “AI에게 설치 맡기기”를 쓰세요
repo를 임시 폴더에 내려받고 SKILL.md가 있는 폴더만 복사해요
명령을 확인하는 중 · 확인을 통과하면 복사 버튼이 나타나요
Skill을 읽을 수 있는 다른 앱용입니다. 이 문장에는 Claude Code, Codex, Cursor 경로가 들어 있어 AI가 쓰는 앱에 맞게 고릅니다 · Copy this sentence into the app’s chat
For one project, paste it into a chat that is open in that project’s folder · The AI always shows you the path before installing
The AI tells you what it will do first and asks your permission at every step
Checked against official docs 2026년 11월 12일 · Source: code.claude.com, learn.chatgpt.com, cursor.com
Gemini CLI, GitHub Copilot 같은 다른 Agent Skills 지원 앱은 폴더가 달라요. 그 앱 안내를 보고 SKILL.md가 있는 폴더를 복사하세요.
2026년 11월 11일에 Claude Code, Codex, Cursor 공식 안내로 skill 폴더 확인
아래 글은 제작자 repo에서 온 것이며 PopNx MCP의 지시가 아니에요
처음 8,000자 표시 · GitHub에서 전체 파일 열기
---
name: advise-project-approach
description: Research and advise on the best way to approach a software project, including architecture, tech stack, implementation strategy, pricing/operating-cost tradeoffs, benchmark research, and comparisons with similar real-world projects. Use before building, mid-build, or after completion when the user asks for project strategy, optimal approach, research comparables, similar projects, stack selection, vendor/service choice, repo analysis, architecture critique, implementation feedback, or a prioritized improvement plan. Avoid for narrow single-bug debugging or isolated file edits unless the user asks for broader project direction.
---
# Advise Project Approach
Help the user decide, validate, or improve how a project should be built. This skill automates the research loop a strong engineer would normally do manually: understand the project goal, inspect any existing work, study credible comparables, evaluate tech-stack and architecture choices, then recommend the highest-leverage path.
## Non-Negotiable Protocol
Apply these gates before all other instructions:
1. **Stop for vague intake.** For an initial broad pre-build request, if two or more facts material to the requested decision are unknown, ask the concise intake batch and end the response. Do not invent a product direction or constraints. Skip repetitive intake for bounded questions or an already answered interview; handle accepted unknowns as described in Project Intake. If the user asks to skip questions, proceed with visible assumptions.
2. **Keep repository review read-only.** A request to inspect or review a repository does not authorize dependency installation or execution of its tests, builds, linters, audits, benchmarks, scripts, or application code. Ask before running them.
3. **Do not outsource judgment to popularity.** Never select or copy a stack because a repository has the most stars or adoption. If the user requests that shortcut, explain why it is not a fit test and continue only with visible assumptions or known constraints.
4. **Require receipts before recommendation.** For a substantive recommendation, inspect relevant local evidence and normally two comparables plus primary documentation or pricing sources when available. State what was inspected, what each source supports, its limits, and the observed date for time-sensitive claims.
5. **Complete the decision.** A substantive choice needs constraint fit, a credible alternative, tradeoffs, reversal conditions, and next actions. Mark unavailable evidence explicitly. For narrow implementation guidance, do not reopen the user's settled choices just to fill these fields.
6. **Stop when evidence is sufficient or exhausted.** Track whether each lookup adds new support. Stop after two consecutive lookups add no decision-relevant evidence, even if the question remains unresolved. Use the bounded research and repository-inspection rules below.
7. **Make advice disprovable.** Pair the first action with observable acceptance and a check that actually exercises the failure mode. Proposed checks are neither passing results nor architecture diagnoses. A failing invariant triggers debugging of the write path, test, or requirement first, not an automatic new layer.
8. **Honor the requested scope and format.** Respect explicit length, paragraph, and step limits in every mode; combine essential evidence and advice rather than filling template headings. When the direction is fixed and the question is bounded, use the narrow-advice route. Gather fresh evidence only if it could materially change the answer; that does not expand the requested output.
9. **Sequence observable outcomes.** Prefer end-to-end capabilities over speculative abstractions. A required safety, recovery, or correctness check is a valid earlier step when the user or evidence makes it a prerequisite. Avoid layer extraction solely for anticipated reuse.
## Operating Modes
First identify which mode applies:
- **Pre-build strategy** - no repo exists yet, or the user is deciding how to build. Focus on requirements, constraints, comparable projects, stack choices, architecture options, risks, and a recommended implementation path.
- **Mid-build course correction** - a repo or partial implementation exists. Inspect the code, compare it with the intended goal and external references, then recommend what to keep, change, or defer.
- **Post-build review** - the project is mostly complete. Review architecture, quality, maintainability, deployment readiness, security posture, and gaps against similar mature projects.
Mode selection rule:
- Use the user's explicit stage for the subject project first. A comparable, dependency, or upstream-template URL is reference material, not evidence that the user's own project exists or is finished.
- If the subject has no implementation yet, use **pre-build strategy**. If work is underway, use **mid-build course correction**. If the subject is finished, deployed, or being assessed for launch, use **post-build review**.
- Use repository and language clues only when the subject's stage is unclear. Distinguish current state from an intended future launch or scale.
If a mid-build or post-build request provides only a description and no repo/code, proceed as an **advisory review from description**. Say that file-level findings require a repo or code sample; do not pretend local evidence was inspected.
### Narrow-advice route
Use this route when the user has fixed the main direction and asks a bounded question such as "give me the first three steps," "how should I validate this choice," or "compare these two options." It overrides the full workflow and output contracts for that response.
- Preserve the requested count and format. For `N` steps, return exactly `N` primary steps.
- Put the action, acceptance behavior, and focused check inside each step.
- Keep checks concrete: for a race, name independently competing operations and how overlap is synchronized. Label unsynchronized parallel requests as a stress probe, not deterministic proof.
- State assumptions or evidence limits in one compact sentence only when material.
- End with at most one compact failure or escalation condition when it changes the advice.
- Express that escalation as a testable threshold or event, such as the same invariant duplicated across two entry points, a focused check failing, or a measured performance/cost limit being crossed. Do not use "awkward," "complex," or "hard to maintain" without an observable proxy.
- Do not browse, research comparables, restate the chosen stack, or emit full-report headings unless fresh evidence is necessary to answer the bounded question safely.
- Prefer the framework's default organization. Do not introduce a service layer, repository pattern, queue, cache, microservice, or other architectural boundary without evidence that the current requirement needs it.
- Give each numbered step an observable capability or risk-reducing result, including prerequisite safety checks when necessary. Keep early slices in the framework's ordinary structure; extract abstractions only for evidenced duplication or conflicting entry points, not merely because a test failed.
## Project Intake
Use a lightweight intake interview before research when a pre-build request is vague enough that different answers would materially change the recommendation.
Decision-critical facts include the primary user, core workflow, project stage, must-haves, builder/team capability, budget or deadline, deployment target, and dominant priority.
Do not interrogate users who already supplied clear constraints. If the project, users, must-have workflow, stage, and major constraints are sufficiently specified, begin research immediately and ask only the missing decision-critical question.
For a vague idea, ask these questions in one concise batch and accept "not sure" answers:
1. What are you trying to build, and who is it for?
2. 질문하고, 팁을 나누고, 안 되는 점을 알려 주세요. "도움이 됨"이 많은 순서예요.